U.S. manufacturing is poised for a breakout, but the last mile seems impossibly hard

The business leaders who navigate America’s diminished supply chain to successfully manufacture in the U.S. also carry with them a hard-edged realism about domestic production.

The facts on the ground are these: It’s damn hard in many cases to travel the last mile, to see it through with U.S. fabricators and suppliers when so many core manufacturing capabilities, materials, and expertise are elusive. Or offshore.

Pete Wagner makes award-winning skis from an idyllic perch in Telluride, Colorado. His innovation is changing the sport: Skiers provide a full range of biometrics to optimize the performance “fit” of a ski, information that’s processed by Wagner’s technology suite to fully customize the product for a buyer. It’s every bit the digitization of American manufacturing we read about weekly.

Yet to the extent manufacturing’s digital evolution is key to its future, it’s not the primary barrier for Wagner to make skis in the U.S.

“Our company, our brand, is all about American-made and sourcing everything we possibly can in the U.S.,” Wagner says. “But occasionally we run into an issue that speaks to what U.S. manufacturing has lost.”

Wagner offered the example of his national search for a key component. “We buy an anodized aluminum alloy from a company in Austria that’s used in our skis. I wanted to source the material from a U.S. company,” he explains. “I figured it must be available for aerospace or other applications. I talked with some great people in the U.S. aluminum industry. After getting material analysis done, I was told that we can’t get a similar type of high performance alloy material in that configuration from a U.S supplier.

“It makes you question how much we value manufacturing in the U.S.,” he adds. “Or, it’s just a smart business decision, given the global market. Either way, it makes it tough.”

Wagner’s frustration plays out by orders of magnitude for other companies, and for entire industries, including his own. Wagner Custom Skis is an anomaly in America’s burgeoning outdoor industry; few of its leading companies are committed to U.S. production. Some can’t. Some don’t try. So the topic is largely avoided, or relegated to the back burner by other more positive story lines.

Others are less sanguine about America’s industrial state, including the Pentagon. Metalcraft Industries CEO Larry Caschette pointed me to a U.S. Department of Defense Industrial Capabilities Report to Congress with this rather grim assessment:

“[The] Department of Defense is still the colossus of the federal system, i.e., the single biggest buyer of goods in the U.S. government. But unless the industrial and manufacturing base that develops and builds those goods modernizes and adjusts to the world’s new geopolitical and economic realities, America will face a growing and likely permanent national security deficit.”

Caschette is encouraging manufacturing enthusiasts to tag the report in messages to elected officials to reinforce the findings. Framing U.S. manufacturing as a “national security” issue certainly gets the attention of elected types.

It’s also hard to imagine how the DoD’s prescription comes to fruition without more vigorous public sector support. Per the report, a “national defense industrial strategy” is needed, a four-part program to:

  1. Reshore our defense industrial base and supply chains to the United States and to allies, starting with microelectronics, and restore our shipbuilding base.
  2. Build a modern manufacturing and engineering workforce and research and development (R&D) base.
  3. Continue to modernize the defense acquisition process to fit 21st century realities.
  4. Find new ways to partner private sector innovation with public sector resources and demand. All these steps will be necessary to create a robust, resilient, secure, and innovative industrial base.

It’s stuff we write about every week.

But how much will government intervention truly help, even with a new and exciting “industrial strategy,” to reshore our industrial base? Can the U.S. government also build a modern R&D ecosystem?

American companies in part funded China’s world-class supply chain. Cheap labor and short-term profits were too hard to pass up. Now it’s up to us to bring it home. Let’s earmark substantial public sector support to hasten its reshoring as we take matters into our hands.

One good outcome would be locating anodized aluminum alloy for an intrepid American manufacturer. Let’s work on a thousand more. One company at a time.

Bart Taylor is publisher of CompanyWeek. Contact him with a source or supplier for Wagner Custom Skis, or reach him at btaylor@companyweek.com.

Shut the front door: Why NAM’s Trump rebuke is a shocker

To say I was surprised to read Jay Timmons, president and CEO of the National Association of Manufacturers, encouraging Vice President Mike Pence last week to remove Donald Trump from office by invoking the 25th Amendment would be an understatement.

I’ve met Timmons several times and of course follow NAM on any number of issues impacting manufacturing. More than not, I’ve questioned NAM’s relevance, its connectedness, to a manufacturing sector overwhelmingly composed of small manufacturers that share very little in the spoils of the association’s big-company funded work.

NAM is also a political organization, and its politics tilt right. Timmons tacitly acknowledged as much in his statement last week. At times, the organization’s conservative posture has hamstrung its ability to speak for a sector busting out along progressive lines. I said as much in a 2015 column, “NAM’s love/hate relationship with President Obama reflects industry in transition”:

Taken as a whole, [NAM’s] well-intentioned if somewhat confusing policy evolution reflects an industry in transition. Manufacturing is changing. It’s tech-driven — digital; it’s agile, small business; it’s young and lifestyle-driven to suit trends and changing consumer preferences; it’s beer and organic food at the same time it’s steel and paper, fabricating and welding.

It’s changing and NAM and Timmons are trying hard to adapt — however confusing and disruptive the journey may be.

Yet Timmons wasted no time in breaking from the president. He could have waited. The certainty, the immediacy of NAM’s pronouncement, was a surprise. Was it courageous? Maybe. It certainly wasn’t easy given Timmons’, and NAM’s, history.

Today, as I read my past comments about NAM and Timmons, I admit my own perspective has also changed. It’s a good time to fess up. In a 2018 column, “NAM’s politics shortchange small manufacturers,” I argued for “reducing — not expanding — import restrictions and tariffs on targeted raw material categories to enhance local and regional supply chains.”

Today I’m a proponent of a trade strategy that protects U.S. manufacturers in select industries with whatever means are effective, including tariffs. We require no more evidence of the harmful effects of unfettered globalization, including unreciprocated access to offshore markets, to American companies and workers.

A position that leaves me, again, at odds with NAM. Yet for one week, during these incredible times, all manufacturers can celebrate Jay Timmons and hope that America’s preeminent manufacturing association can next time convince a vice president to do the right thing.

Bart Taylor is publisher of CompanyWeek. Reach him at btaylor@companyweek.com.

Five predictions for California manufacturing in 2021

In February 2020, I said this about California manufacturing employment:

In sum, California is well-positioned for growth in the industries that promise to reshape U.S. manufacturing; to capture a higher percentage of the domestic jobs that do materialize in the 2020’s. For every job lost in apparel manufacturing, others are materializing across the region. Will they materialize here?

Since then, we know that COVID-19 has accelerated trends that were favoring domestic manufacturing before the pandemic, and that California stands to benefit. Here, then, are five predictions for California manufacturing in 2021, a year that stands to end much better than how it’s beginning, with a percentage guess as to the likelihood of each coming true:

1. Manufacturing’s beachhead expands as more companies evaluate domestic production options

The local and regional manufacturing comeback we chronicle every month is now a national story. In “Five Predictions For The Manufacturing Industry in 2021,” Forbes columnist Amar Hanspa belatedly forecasts:

We’ll see a shift to localized production. In 2021, the industrial manufacturing sector will take a page from the consumer-driven “farm to table” trend that has taken hold in the agriculture industry over the last decade, with a shift to localized production. This will primarily be driven by the threat of ongoing trade war/tariffs threatening global supply chains, encouraging manufacturers to move production activity closer to the customer. In the future, manufacturers will want to build where they sell for several reasons, including faster time to market, lower working capital, government policies, and increased resiliency. This won’t be an easy or overnight shift.

The “shift” is already underway. In California, that spells growth. The state is already an epicenter to companies in established industries like food, beverage, aerospace, and energy. Expect growth in new industries and sectors that have been more resistant to onshore production, like consumer and medical products, outdoor industry, and precision-machined parts.

Harry Moser, founder of the Reshoring Initiative and an authority on the economics of domestic production, ranked his top three sectors for CompanyWeek: “The hottest items in 2020 and 2021 are PPE and other medical products such as antibiotics,” he says, noting that “60 percent of companies reshoring production since March 2020 mentioned COVID as one cause.”

Moser continues, “Second, other essential or politically timely items with supply chain gaps, such as rare earth minerals, defense materiel, electronics, solar, and wind. Then, anything else now coming from China. Biden has said he will not end the China tariffs soon” — meaning companies manufacturing in China will be in the hunt for domestic options.

It adds up to a growth year for U.S. — and California manufacturing.

Likelihood: 80%

2. Free trade is dead

Even before COVID, tariffs exposed America’s sub-par manufacturing supply chain, but more, the lack of a trade strategy. As The Wall Street Journal noted, Trump tariffs resulted in a mishmash of outcomes that benefitted well-connected companies, but left others wanting.

Forget the notion of unfettered globalization — even for a top 10 global economy like California’s. State officials should lobby for targeted protection in promising local industries like bioscience, where cheap and subpar Asian products handicap manufacturers and force healthcare buyers to choose products made offshore.

President-elect Joe Biden has signaled a renewed commitment to manufacturing through the invaluable NIST MEP network. It’s a great start. California Governor Gavin Newsom and his team at the Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) must also take the lead on a regional plan that protects and accelerates promising manufacturing industries.

Likelihood: 15%

3. A small but influential cadre of pro-California manufacturers will push back on the relocation narrative

More a wish than a prediction, perhaps, but one silver lining from the steady stream of high-profile exits is that pro-CA companies begin to push back on the narrative.

And why not? As manufacturing’s brand ascends, California’s manufacturing assets become more valuable. Its R&D ecosystem is second to none, spinning off both technologies and companies that are changing domestic production to the core. But the depth and expertise of businesses in CA’s supply chain, in key industries like aerospace and transportation, is the state’s unheralded attribute.

With such quality companies, captained by California advocates like Pamela Kan at Bishop-Wisecarver, and Hale Foote at Scandic (read Inside the Tesla supply chain: Hale Foote and Scandic), and others that comprise CompanyWeek’s cadre of California Leaders, manufacturing in California is in a position to make positive noise.

Will it?

Likelihood: 50%

4. Workforce health will become big business, and manufacturers will play a leading role

Manufacturing’s stock rose in ’20 in part because U.S. companies rushed in to fill the void in PPE. The trend continues in ’21 as manufacturers innovate to build solutions that keep our public places safe, but more, keep factories and consumer-facing production facilities like breweries and restaurants open.

It’s the latest noble endeavor for a sector that built the arsenal of democracy and landed a man on the Moon. Coronaviruses have no chance.

Likelihood: 60%

5. The FDA will finally provide regulatory certainty for hemp cannabis producers — and the cannabis industry will explode.

It’s unfathomable that we lack official data as to how many employees work in the state’s billion dollar cannabis industry; how many work in manufacturing vs. other functional areas; how many work at state-regulated, federally illegal THC producers vs. unregulated but federally legal hemp companies; or how much of the growth manifest in chemical or food manufacturing the past few years is attributable to cannabis.

When, in 2021, the FDA regulates hemp-derived CBD products as a dietary supplement or food additive (or both), California’s cannabis ecosystem will leap forward, again. For suppliers and service companies, ambivalent about cannabis today, it will be too late to jump on the bandwagon. Get aligned, find industry partners, advocate for the Golden State’s homegrown industry — or watch from the sidelines.

Likelihood: 90%

Bonus forecast: CompanyWeek will report on 300 manufacturers in 2021

Here’s how we can help your company in 2021: If you haven’t been featured in CompanyWeek, send a note to Editor Eric Peterson to get on the editorial schedule.

The CompanyWeek “tribe” will expand in ’21 and along with it, contact and connections with new business and trade partners.

Likelihood: 95%

Buh-bye ’20. Hello ’21.

Bart Taylor is publisher of CompanyWeek. Reach him at btaylor@companyweek.com.

Five Colorado manufacturing predictions for 2021

Here was my forecast a year ago of five Colorado manufacturing storylines for 2020:

  1. Food’s undersized brand gets a lift
  2. Technology’s oversized reputation gets an overhaul
  3. Will Colorado’s global manufacturing brands engage more locally?
  4. Industrial cannabis is here. Like, right here.
  5. It won’t always be this easy

I was partly right: 2020 certainly wasn’t easy! Let’s dispense with last year and forecast the promising year ahead.

Here are five Colorado manufacturing predictions for 2021, with a percentage guess as to the likelihood of each coming true:

1. Manufacturing’s beachhead expands as more companies evaluate domestic production options

The local and regional manufacturing comeback we chronicle every week is now a national story. In Five Predictions For The Manufacturing Industry In 2021, Forbes columnist Amar Hanspa belatedly forecasts:

We’ll see a shift to localized production. In 2021, the industrial manufacturing sector will take a page from the consumer-driven “farm to table” trend that has taken hold in the agriculture industry over the last decade, with a shift to localized production. This will primarily be driven by the threat of ongoing trade war/tariffs threatening global supply chains, encouraging manufacturers to move production activity closer to the customer. In the future, manufacturers will want to build where they sell for several reasons, including faster time to market, lower working capital, government policies, and increased resiliency. This won’t be an easy or overnight shift.

The “shift” is already underway. In Colorado, that spells growth. The state is on fire with companies in established industries like food, beverage, aerospace, and energy. Expect growth in new industries and sectors that have been more resistant to onshore production, like consumer and medical products, outdoor industry, and precision-machined parts.

Harry Moser, founder of the Reshoring Initiative and an authority on the economics of domestic production, ranked his top three sectors for CompanyWeek: “The hottest items in 2020 and 2021 are PPE and other medical products such as antibiotics,” he says, noting that “60 percent of companies reshoring production since March 2020 mentioned COVID as one cause.”

Moser continues, “Second, other essential or politically timely items with supply chain gaps, such as rare earth minerals, defense materiel, electronics, solar, and wind. Then, anything else now coming from China. Biden has said he will not end the China tariffs soon” — meaning companies manufacturing in China will be in the hunt for domestic options.

It adds up to a growth year for U.S. — and Colorado manufacturing.

Likelihood: 80%

2. Free trade is dead

Even before COVID, tariffs exposed America’s sub-par manufacturing supply chain, but more, the lack of a trade strategy. As The Wall Street Journal noted, Trump tariffs resulted in a mishmash of outcomes that benefitted well-connected companies, but left others wanting.

Instead, Colorado’s D.C. contingent should lobby for targeted protection in promising local industries like bioscience, where cheap and subpar Asian products handicap manufacturers here. President-elect Joe Biden has signaled a renewed commitment to manufacturing through the invaluable NIST MEP network. It’s a great start. Colorado Governor Jared Polis and his team at the Office of Economic Development and International Trade don’t set trade policy, but can also lead with a regional plan that accelerates promising manufacturing industries and fuels a more capable supply chain.

Manufacturing is “essential” again, free trade is an outdated notion, and a new U.S. industrial strategy should use tariffs and other tactics to protect key manufacturing industries and jobs.

Likelihood: 15%

3. Tactics to recruit and support manufacturing in Colorado get better

With the benefits of domestic manufacturing now in focus, the tactics to recruit companies and sustain more local production are improving. And it’s all about the supply chain. In 2020, companies responding to COVID-related supply-chain disruptions often stared down a lack of viable domestic options. This must change — and will, even if incremental improvements are the ’21 reality.

New manufacturing “places” are also fueling innovation in the supply chain. Real estate developments designed for “clusters” of complementary manufacturing businesses should continue to proliferate. Grand Junction, Fort Collins/Loveland, Montrose, Boulder County — these communities are in the game. Who will follow? And will it be enough to compete on a national scale?

Likelihood: 50%

4. Workforce health will become big business, and manufacturers will play a leading role

Manufacturing’s stock rose in ’20 in part because U.S. companies rushed in to fill the void in PPE. The trend continues in ’21 as manufacturers innovate to build solutions that keep our public places safe, but more, keep factories and consumer-facing production facilities like breweries and restaurants open.

It’s the latest noble endeavor for a sector that built the arsenal of democracy and landed a man on the Moon. Coronaviruses have no chance.

Likelihood: 60%

5. The FDA will finally provide regulatory certainty for hemp cannabis producers — and Colorado’s cannabis industry will explode

It’s unfathomable that we lack official data as to how many employees work in the state’s $1.5 billion cannabis industry; how many work in manufacturing vs. other functional areas; how many work at state-regulated, federally illegal THC producers vs. unregulated but federally legal hemp companies; or how much of the growth manifest in chemical or food manufacturing the past few years is attributable to cannabis.

Here’s what we know: When, in 2021, the FDA regulates hemp-derived CBD products as a dietary supplement or food additive (or both), the state’s nation-leading cannabis ecosystem will leap forward, again. For suppliers and service companies, ambivalent about cannabis today, it will be too late to jump on the bandwagon. Get aligned, find industry partners, advocate for Colorado’s homegrown industry — or watch from the sidelines.

Likelihood: 90%

Bonus forecast: CompanyWeek will report on 300 manufacturers in 2021

Here’s how we can help your company in 2021: If you haven’t been featured in CompanyWeek, send a note to Editor Eric Peterson to get on the editorial schedule. The CompanyWeek “tribe” will expand in ’21 and along with it, contact and connections with new business and trade partners.

Likelihood: 95%

Buh-bye ’20. Hello ’21.

Bart Taylor is publisher of CompanyWeek. Reach him atbtaylor@companyweek.com.